Can My Dog and I Be Forced to Use the Service Elevator?

Can My Dog and I Be Forced to Use the Service Elevator?

Q: I dwell in an Higher West Facet apartment with quite a few lease-stabilized residences. A number of months in the past, all the residents — both of those renters and entrepreneurs — received a threatening letter from the handling agent stating that the board can impose fines on tenants if they get their dogs outside the house through the foyer. As a substitute, we should use a support elevator and exit through a very long support hallway, equally of which are usually whole of obstructions because they are utilised by contractors and servicing staff. Tenants must carry their canine in the elevator now, much too. Are these principles and fines authorized?

A: This is the kind of rule that is not uniformly enforceable, and could be challenged by some of the people.

Initial, the board may possibly run into opposition from any one whose pet is an emotional-aid animal, since the city’s Human Rights Regulation provides those people proprietors significant legal rights. Another person with an psychological-guidance pet is entitled to equivalent use and satisfaction of their residence.

“They can’t be forced to take a services elevator, or go out some other entrance, especially if that other entrance is, say, out the back, or in a considerably less harmless put, or by means of the basement,” reported Darryl M. Vernon, a authentic estate lawyer who represents folks with companion animals.


A resident with a incapacity could obstacle the rule below federal, condition and nearby incapacity guidelines. An individual with mobility troubles or back again difficulties, for illustration, may possibly not be able to have a pet on the elevator, or may get worried about tripping hazards. That resident could request a reasonable lodging, these as employing the lobby and the passenger elevator.

Rent-stabilized tenants also have protections, and are not ruled by condominium procedures. Rather, they are governed by the terms of their lease and stabilization guidelines, indicating management are unable to implement property policies on them. Further than that, landlords are not able to cost rent-stabilized tenants more than their hire, making it probably that these fines are unenforceable. If the authentic stabilized lease does not incorporate a rule about walking puppies out the back door or utilizing the services elevator for them, the rule cannot be included later on. “This pretty effectively adds up to illegal and actionable harassment by this landlord,” Mr. Vernon said.

The landlord could, having said that, implement the rule for market-rate tenants and device proprietors without the need of any disability claims. Unit owners are subject matter to the residence regulations, which the board can change. And a sector-level lease may include things like terms that demand the tenant to observe the regulations of the condo.

On the other hand, because so several tenants might be entitled to a move, administration may well have a difficult time implementing fines sporadically.

For weekly electronic mail updates on household serious estate news, signal up here. Adhere to us on Twitter: @nytrealestate.